Mathematical Modeling Handbooks I, II, and III were prepared at Teacher College Columbia University and published by the Consortium for Mathematics and its Applications [COMAP] to support the Common Core State Standards in mathematical modeling. Each of the three handbooks focuses on a specific aspect of modeling implementation: modeling content, evaluation of modeling performance, and planning modeling instruction.
Mathematical Modeling Handbook I
You need great materials to teach mathematical modeling as mandated by the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (CCSSM). The Teachers College Mathematical Modeling Handbook is the ideal text to do just that.
Helping students develop a mathematical disposition encourages recognition of mathematical opportunities in everyday events. The TC Mathematical Modeling Handbook bolsters the CCSSM approach to interpret modeling not as a collection of isolated topics but in relation to the content standards. The Handbook provides modules containing teacher guides, student activities, possible solutions and natural classroom extensions for over 25 topics, together with references to specific modeling standards for which the topics may be appropriate.
Mathematical Modeling Handbook II: The Assessments
Mathematical Handbook II: The Assessments - What does it mean to be able to mathematically model successfully? Modeling has several aspects as we know from the structure of the modeling cycle. Moreover, performance-based assessments are difficult to construct and difficult to grade. This second Handbook represents our attempt to provide several alternate assessment modes for each of the original modules in Handbook I.
Mathematical Modeling Handbook III: Lesson Paradigms
The authors of Handbook III approached the planning of mathematical modeling lessons with a broader brush than is customary for more commonplace topics from algebra and geometry. Traditional planning templates may be ill-suited to modeling instruction since the same modeling topic could be approached from many directions depending upon the capabilities of the students and the knowledge of the teacher. For example, the module entitled Unstable Table could be approached from an experimental standpoint with an actual table on an uneven floor or from a sophisticated, three dimensional geometric point of view.
Mathematical Modeling Handbook I
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Mathematical Modeling Modules
COULD KING KONG EXIST? 1-10
When watching the movie King Kong, moviegoers are swept away with the idea of a gigantic gorilla capable
of running around, climbing with ease, and, most importantly, saving Ann Darrow from harm. But could
this animal really exist? In this two-day lesson, students will investigate surface area, volume, and bone
strength to determine if his existence is mathematically possible.
A MODEL SOLAR SYSTEM 11-20
In this two-day lesson, students will create several scale models of the Solar System using everyday items.
Open with discussing the size of the universe and aim to steer the conversation towards the size of the
astronomical bodies. Pose questions that make students think about how large one astronomical body is
compared to another. How can they create a model that considers the scale of the bodies?
FOR THE BIRDS 21-28
In this two-day lesson, students are challenged to consider the different physical factors that affect real world
models. Students are asked to find out how long it will take a bird feeder — with a constant stream of
birds feeding at it — to empty completely.
To begin, explain that the students will be watching over a neighbor’s home. This neighbor is an ornithologist
(a scientist that studies birds) with a bird feeder to be looked after. Humans can’t come around too often
because it will frighten the birds, but they also can’t come around too infrequently because the birds will
leave if the feeder frequently is empty. The students need to find out when to come back and fill the feeder
to ensure that the neighbor and the birds are all happy.
ON SAFARI 29-38
In this two-day lesson, students determine the best way to schedule their time while out on a safari. With
only four hours to be out they must use the probabilities of seeing an animal species to determine how
much time they should spend there before moving on. The probabilities change with the amount of time
spent at a location.
By determining the expected number of animal species seen, students see that the ideal amount of time
spent at each location is neither the maximum value nor the minimum value. They justify their conclusion
about scheduling using a graph and the slopes of lines from the origin.
CHOOSING A COLLEGE 39-48
In this two-day lesson, students determine their best-matched college. They use decision-making strategies
based on their preferences and ranked choices. This lesson guides students through the process of selecting
a list of choices and rating these choices based on their preferences in order to find the college most
suited to their preferences and requirements.
A TOUR OF JAFFA 49-58
In this two-day lesson, students will model a graph optimization problem called the “Traveling Salesman
Problem” (TSP). The TSP seeks to minimize the cost of the route a salesperson should follow to visit a set of
cities and return to home. The goal is to find a minimal-cost Hamilton circuit in a complete graph having an
associated cost array, M.
To begin, explain the situation to students. They are about to visit a new place such as a zoo, a city, a shopping
center, or an amusement park, and they wish to plan their trip beforehand. What should they consider
when planning their trip? How would they plan the most efficient route?
GAUGING RAINFALL 59-66
In this two-day lesson, students will estimate the average rainfall for a 16 km by 18 km territory in
Rajasthan, India. Rainfall estimations will be based on rain gauges scattered around the territory. Since
these placements are varied, students will need to identify each gauge’s “region of influence” to estimate
the average rainfall.
To begin, explain the situation that needs to be modeled. Meteorologists need to understand average rainfall
totals in a region in order to make short-term forecasts. These are usually for relatively shorter periods
of time. Climatologists need to understand average rainfall totals for relatively longer periods of time in
order to understand, among other things, climate change.
NARROW CORRIDOR 67-76
In this two-day lesson, students are asked to determine whether large, long, and bulky objects fit around
the corner of a narrow corridor.
The objective of this lesson is to apply the concept of turning points (maximum or minimum points) and
the Pythagorean Theorem to determine the longest object that can go around the corner of a corridor.
TALE OF THE TAPE 77-88
In this two-day lesson, students will model the path of a baseball in flight and use that model to determine
how far the ball will travel (in ground distance). Students then use those ideas to apply them to skeet
shooting where they determine not just the flight of the clay disk, but also the flight of the pellet and their
Ideally, the lesson will involve solving a system of linear equations to determine the function and solving a
quadratic equation to find the roots of this function, although other models are encouraged. For some
examples, you may be able to factor to solve the resulting quadratic equation, but if the polynomial is prime,
the quadratic formula, completing the square, or the graphing calculator can be used.
UNSTABLE TABLE 89-100
Have you ever tried to eat on an unstable, tippy table? No doubt drinks and soup were spilled easily!
Restaurant wait staff often fold paper napkins to wedge under one of the legs to stabilize the table.
In this two-day lesson, students learn to stabilize a table without the use of napkins — they can rotate it up
to 90°. The result is counter intuitive but can be verified mathematically.
SUNKEN TREASURE 101-108
In this two-day lesson, students help the crew of a shipwreck recovery team minimize the amount of work
done to remove treasure chests from a ship lost at sea. The divers must move the chests to a rope that is
between their locations coming from the recovery team’s boat above. The captain of the boat’s crew insists
on placing the rope in one spot; he doesn’t want to waste time and money moving it each time a chest is collected.
ESTIMATING TEMPERATURES 109-116
In this two-day lesson, students will model temperature data. They will use “known temperature stations”
in order to estimate temperatures at any given point accurately. Websites that give the temperature at a
specific place typically do not give the actual values; they give an estimate based on meteorological data.
Explain to students that temperatures are not measured everywhere and educated estimates need to be
made. Have the students imagine they are meteorologists interested in making a model to estimate temperature
at a given time and at a given location.
BENDING STEEL 117-124
Metal railroad tracks expand and contract due to weather. In this two-day lesson, using the assumption that
a railroad track is secured at both ends, students will use models to estimate how expansion of the track
affects the height of the rail off the ground. Sometimes tracks will expand outward along the ground, but
this lesson focuses on the case where they expand upward.
Interestingly, very small increases in length as a result of expansion have a large effect on height. Students
will investigate this phenomenon using both triangular and arc models.
A BIT OF INFORMATION 125-134
In this two-day lesson, students will learn to use a logarithmic function to model information functions. A
significant portion of the secondary curriculum revolves around the analysis of functional relationships. In
the context of computers, the notion of sending and receiving information gives way to an interesting relationship
between the required length of code and how much information it carries.
In fact, this represents one of very few real world situations where only a logarithmic function can model
STATE APPORTIONMENT 135-142
A new country is being formed in this two-day lesson. Students will determine how to allot the representation
for the different states in the country, also known as apportionment.
Begin by asking students how democracy works in the US Ask them how a country that is newly forming
and wishes to adopt a similar representation system to the US might pick how many representatives each
state gets. What different mathematical ways are there to model this?
RATING SYSTEMS 143-150
In this two-day lesson, students will model rating systems like those used in many sports. They are asked to
consider the various factors that the human mind employs to “rate” one team over another; they will then
model a way to consider these factors in order to make a systematic, mathematical rating method. Note that
even professional rating systems often are disputed for their “accuracy”: such is the nature of both mathematical
modeling and sports!
Begin with the description of the situation: you are trying to compare teams or players, but not every
team/player plays the other, so there is no clear “clean-cut” method. How can you devise a system to do
THE WHE TO PLAY 151-158
In this two-day lesson, students develop different strategies to play a game in order to win. In particular,
they will develop a mathematical formula to calculate potential profits at strategic points in the game and
revise strategies based on their predictions.
Allow students to imagine that they are living in the twin islands of Trinidad and Tobago where a popular
game called Play Whe is played everyday. They can think of the game as an investment opportunity and
their goal is always to realize a profit. How can they devise a strategy so that their expenditure is always
less than their potential winnings?
WATER DOWN THE DRAIN 159-168
In this two-day lesson, students will collect data from a water dripping experiment. The data that the students
collect will be the basis for estimating how much water is wasted from typical leaky faucets. At the
beginning of the lesson, the students are faced with a statistic that states leaky faucets in US homes waste
$10,000,000 worth of water each year. At the end of the lesson, students will have the opportunity to determine
what specifications (homes, faucets, drips/minute) result in that amount of money.
VIRAL MARKETING 169-176
In this two-day lesson, students will model “viral marketing.” Viral marketing refers to a marketing strategy
in which people pass on a message (such as an advertisement) to others, much like diseases and viruses are
To begin, explain that you are interested in starting your own business and you are researching different
marketing strategies to “get the word out.” Viral marketing is one strategy that should be considered. What
is viral marketing and what can be said about it mathematically?
SUNRISE, SUNSET 177-184
In this two-day lesson, students will examine changes in the average monthly sunlight over the course of a
year. They will use actual sunrise and sunset data found on the internet in order to calculate the “length of
an average day” for the chosen city. Students will model the data with a sine curve. The model will be interpreted
and used to make connections to the real world.
SURVEYING THE ANCIENT WORLD 185-194
In this two-day lesson, students will construct and use a simple version of an ancient tool called an
astrolabe. This tool measures the angle between the tool and the horizontal plane. It was used frequently
by ancient surveyors, engineers, astronomers, and seafarers to compute angles and heights.
To introduce the lesson, explain the use of the astrolabe to students and have them imagine that they are
ancient surveyors trying to measure the heights of mountains. The astrolabe only measures angles, though.
How could ancient surveyors complete their task?
PACKERS' PUZZLE 195-204
In this two-day lesson, students consider ways to estimate the number of spheres that will fit within a container.
They also will try to pack as many as possible into differently shaped containers.
The objective of this lesson is to have students use geometric solids so that they can solve basic packing
problems that arise in the real world.
FLIPPING FOR A GRADE 205-214
In this two-day lesson, students play different coin-flipping games and try to understand what the outcomes
may be. The objective of this lesson is to understand the meaning of expected value and standard
deviation and why they are so important.
PRESCIENT GRADING 215-226
In this two-day lesson, students will learn how to approximate test grades given homework grades. They
will construct a scatter plot and use the line of best fit to predict grades, as well as examine the effect the
correlation coefficient and the residual have on the predictions.
PICKING A PAINTING 227-234
In this two-day lesson, students are asked to choose the best possible painting from a group provided to
them. Certain restrictions prevent students from going back to previously viewed paintings, so choosing the
best is not as straightforward as just looking at all of them and deciding.
The objective of this lesson is to use ordering and logical thinking to create probabilistic strategies that have
greater chances of success than just random selection. Conditional probability is also explored as a way to
evaluate the strategies further.
CHANGING IT UP 235-242
In this two-day lesson, students will examine the United States monetary system and make mathematical
judgments about how to stock a cash register till (the drawer containing the money that “pops out” of the
register). Different situations are modeled, each time refining the initial model.
Introduce the students to the situation to be modeled: a cash register till needs to be stocked with extra
coin rolls. Cashiers want to try to run out of all the types of change at about the same time so they need to
cash in for new change as rarely as possible. Under-stocking doesn’t work because running out of coins too
frequently results in longer waiting times for customers, and supervisors have to supply more change for
the cashier. The till cannot be overstocked with coin rolls because it will be too heavy and will be very slow